You can copy in the good ones from the LD13 theme list or add new themes!
As a general rule, try to avoid themes that either require specific cultural knowledge (including sports), or impose implementation limitations (like “2-bit color”). Please use alphabetical ordering so it's easy to see if a certain theme is already added.
Themes go here:
best online poker site
April the Twentieth
Astrobiology
Attraction
Autobiography
Bicycle
Board Game
Body parts
Bosses
Breaking the rules
Cactus
Cards
Chain reaction
Circuits
Collecting
Cooperation
Conspiracy
Control
Corpse Stacking
Coffee
Cryogenics/Cryonics
Cyberspace
Dark Ages
Data Collection and Analysis
Death
Defense
Depression
Distorted perception
Don't think, do.
Drums and drumming.
Economics
Educational (If kid's can learn the names of all hundred-dozen-some-odd Pokemon, why can't they learn about something real?)
Epidemic
Ergonomics
Eroticism
Explosions
Extremes
Evil, defeat the lone hero!
Evolution
Fail to win
Ferrets
Flat
Flora and Fauna
Fluoride
Flying
Four Seasons.
Game of life ( as in
"this", but with broader interpretation)
Game within a game
Genetic
Geometry
Giant Naked Men (Dr. Manhattan?) [Or, indeed, any other giant naked men that may come to mind]
Gladiators
Globe
God(s) (or religion)
Government Conspiracy
Gravity
Greedy
Gulliver's Travels
Help the helpless
HG Wells Story
High
Hold the Line
Invasive advertisements
Infinity
Irony
I accidentally the whole thing
Jules Verne Story
King
Kittens
Lasers and Mirrors
Laser Cats
Layers
Leprechauns
Linguistics/Translation/Interpretation
Lots of different endings
Love
Meat vs. Vegetables
Microscopic World
Mirror
Mons
Mountain Goats
Multiple types of health meters
Music
Nachos
Nintendo Hard
Non euclidean space ←– Noooooooo!!!! I hate hyperbolic geometry!

Non Sequitur
Nude beach management
One Hit Point Wonder
One way out
Online high scores
Opposites
Over-complication
Over-simplification
Overlords
Paper
Perpetual motion
Player's actions coming back to bite him/her in the keister
Pollution
Procedural Generation
Psychedelic
Psychology
Psychonauts
Purposed Play (playing the game aides productivity)
Quanta
Quantum physics
Queues
Radiation
Rain
Randomness (never the same twice)
Reality TV
-
Red Herring
Reflection
Relationships
Renaissance
Reverse Engineering
Revolt
Rewind
Robot
Rogue Nanobots
Role Reversal
Roman Empire
Roundabout methods
Sandbox
Scheme
Science Fiction
Sex
Short Complete Story
Sickeningly Cute
Single Enemy
Simplexity (complexity emerging from a simple design)
Sniping
Source of reality
Spicy
Spinning
Squids
Springs
Social interaction
Stab the Pope
Synesthesia
Taxes
Time traveling
To be played in a public place
Toaster
Toys
Track
Transport
Turn-based strategy
Turbo Hyper Ultra Mega Laser Ninjas 3000
Two versions of the same thing
Tycoon
Universal
User designed entities(Machines/Gadgets/Organisms)
Versus
Very Short Games
Water Pressure
Werewolves
What I did last weekend… the game!
Wikipedia (the site somehow plays into the game's design)
Winamp
Winter
Words
Wormholes
Xylophone
Xenophobia
Yetis
Your Mother
Zero Repetition
Zombies
Zapping
WORMS AND ZOMBIES ←- dude, that is *not* alphabetical order ^^
…
(let's not use these again for a while)
LD13: Roads
LD12: The Tower
LD11: Minimalist
LD10.5: Weird/Unexpected/Surprise
LD10: Chain Reaction
LD9: Build the level you play
LD8.5: Moon, Anti-Text
LD8: Swarms
LD7: Growth
LD6: Light and Darkness
LD5: Random
LD4: Infection
LD3: Preparation
LD2: Construction/Destruction (Minor Theme: Sheep)
LD1: Guardian
LD0: Indirect Interaction
Mini LD #8 (Hamumu - March 09): Mash-up
Mini LD #7 (Philhassey - February 09): Cryptozoology
Mini LD #6 (Matrin - January 09): Monochrome
Mini LD #5 (Hamumu - November 08): Cover
Mini LD #4 (Eugman - October 08): MSpaint: Best Level Editor Ever
Mini LD #3 (PoV - September 08): Tool
Mini LD #2 (GirlFlash - July 08): The game of the movie (Minor Theme: Unicorn)
Mini LD #1 (Hamumu - June 08): Versus (Two extremely famous or iconic characters)
72HGDC #8 Nov '06: Magnets
72HGDC #7 Jul '06: Retro
72HGDC #6 Mar '06: Magic
72HGDC #5 Jul '05: Horror
72HGDC #4 Dec '04: Swappable Parts/Customize?
72HGDC #3 Jun '04: Pirates
72HGDC #2 Jan '04: Food
72HGDC #1 Jul '03: Mindless violence
FGDC4: Ball Physics
FGDC3: Replay
FGDC2: Grow
FGDC1: Point & Click