[ Real World Gatherings | Ludum Deals | Warmup Weekend ]
[ MiniLD 47 (Humble Beginnings) | Charity Jam II | October Challenge 2013 ]
Phew! Apologies for the late start on this. You would not believe how busy I’ve been. Click above and help us reduce the nearly 3000 themes suggested down to a more manageable size. Thanks!
This entry was posted
on Wednesday, August 14th, 2013 at 8:24 pm and is filed under LD #27.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Going through this like crazy. Are there any guidelines?
Don’t quote me on this, but I believe the following has generally been true during prior Theme Slaughters:
- Slaughter everything that consists of a technical requirement, because not everyone will be able to meet it. The point of LD is to encourage developers of all levels of experience participate, using whatever means best suith them. This means a lot of different people using a lot of different development pipelines (i.e. programming languages, game engine/libraries, art tools, and so on- which, for most succesful LDers, are decided before the theme is announced). That stuff alone already places different technical requirements on everyone, and it is impossible to make a theme with another technical requirement that takes everyone into account (not even “runs on a computer”- a few LDers have made board games!).
- Similarly, downvote (or maybe slaughter) anything that *explicitly* mentions a specific game genre or art style- again, some people won’t be able to meet it due to the very nature of their development pipeline. Stuff that vaguely suggest mechanics (like “Enemies as Weapons” from LD18) are okay because they don’t exclude any kind of game, but a theme like “Platformers” would not be okay. “Minimalism” from LD26 was okay because the minimalism didn’t necessarily have to be in art style, but “Monochromatic” can pretty much only be interpreted from an art standpoint (remember not every game will have graphics- some people write interactive fiction for LD).
- Other than that, just upvote anything you think would lead to a wide variety of interesting games, and downvote anything else. I tend to downvote anything that suggests a specific setting or narrative genre (like “Space”, “Medieval”, or “Zombies”) because they detract from the variety of the entries, but that’s just my personal preference; they’re perfectly valid themes (they don’t exclude anyone in a technical sense), and many themes like that have made the finals.
Yea, that makes a tonne more sense than what I had in mind. I’d just been
- slaughtering genres that are descriptive of the mechanics (so slaughtering “platformer”, and “fps”, but not “horror”), phrases (stuff like “give me your wallet”), obscure dictionary words, words from other languages, words which can’t qualify as a minutely useful theme (like “kittens” and “puppies”).
- Downvoting repeat themes, since “Evolution” and other themes that always make into the list are there and the majority of non-capitalised words that suggested that someone had put words straight in from the dictionary, and material nouns (“Goblins” is downvoted because it is material, “Ghosts” and “Subversion” are not downvoted because they are immaterial, such is just a trend of sorts I noticed).
- Upvoting stuff which is conducive to freedom of artistic expression and interesting restrictions.
I’m pulling for “Ninja Cats!”
Ha, for a moment I thought “Slaughter” was the theme already
Haha, me too XD
Huzzah. And that flashing banner just makes the process so much more fun
I also though for a moment that it was the theme anouncement to be “slaughter”. Thank god it wasn’t
Huh. I never saw any link to suggest themes. Oh well.
On a side note, my brother thinks the new kittengoatpotato should be cheese. That is all.
I second this motion; but an how about the compromise of cheese AND potatoes?
Omg ’30 second RPG’, thats epic, best idea ive heard so far, kudos to its creator
Related to this, I think it could be interesting to have a theme of “5 minute games”.
Since there are so many games to play in LD, it can be nice to know how long any one game is going to take beforehand. No doubt some developers would interpret this exactly, and include a 5 minute timer which builds up tension to some win-or-lose climax
Unfortunately, the RPG part is a genre, not a theme, but I like sorceress’s version, even if it is a bit broad. I might use that for my Warmup!
is there a list of all the themes in the slaughter currently?
Some of the themes are very interesting so I might want to use some of them in future games.
Could there be a download put together or something?
There’s a theme list from LD22: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AvoAtpvLDdrPdFZ4MTZ4eE5hR1REbTVHSUtZcklyQ3c#gid=0
Amazing idea of reducing the number of themes! I almost couldn’t wait to see some of the suggestions.
I suggest to add a link to translate.google.com/q= for themes in theme slaughter
Oh man, looking at these themes I get scared that the final theme will suck. So many bad themes T_T
That’s what this voting process is for… to filter out the incredibly bland or unusable themes and end up with 30 good ones to vote from. I saw a few great themes in there already, you just gotta keep looking.
I’m pulling for Nostalgia myself. I think it’d be an excellent theme.
Since I’m a relative LD newb, I accidentally voted for a couple of themes that have been previous LD themes.
I just went to Wikipedia to look up all previous themes though, just to prevent this.
(However if the theme ends up being “Growth” or “Evolution”, that’d be my fault `~`)
Totally new here. Glad to see I’m not the only one who spent a little while thinking the theme *was* ‘slaughter’.
Came up with a few ideas too
Also, what’s the point of making a theme “bad” instead of “slaughtering”? I mean, for God’s sake, we have over 3000 themes! If something wouldn’t be a good theme, then forget it!
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Ludum Dare is proudly powered by
and Comments (RSS).
All posts, images, and comments are owned by their creators.